I have a four year old who likes toys. Ok, let’s face it, is there are four year old on this planet who doesn’t like a toy or three? (Cue Frozen theme song: “Let it gooooo!” Obviously followed by tormented parents hastily burying Frozen DVD in the rubbish while child sleeps.)
Me? I don’t have to worry about that so much….you see, the thing is, living in Xi’an – the toy department is a little on the lean side. Olaf and his mates are still a bit of an enigma for kids ’round these parts.
In fact, quite a few of the latest and greatest children’s toys are few and far between in much of China.
There’s this (easily) misguided belief that because (almost) everything is ‘made in China,’ it’s got to be here in abundance, and no less, cheap as chips!
Sadly, I’m here to bring you the bad news: that’s not really the case. (Hence my recent outsourcing via US Global Mail for some Peppa Pig paraphernalia!)
China might be famous as the ‘factory to the world,’ pumping out a myriad of goods, all bearing the ‘Made in China’ stamp, but (and yes I’m truly sorry to burst your bubble) that’s where the love affair with homemade products seemingly ends.
I’m sure things are a little different in a first tier city, so before you start saying, “Oh she’s lost her marbles, I’ve seen Elsa and Anna kicking up a storm in downtown Shanghai!” let it be said, second tier cities are slightly less endowed in the toy department.
Yes, I admit I saw Elsa last week hanging out at a local toy shop up the road. It was the first time she’s graced Xi’an because for the most part, it’s still good old Barbie, roller blades and China’s famous “cartoon goat” all the way…
And at the risk of sending you into a complete frazzle, if you’re after anything more elaborate than say soap and toothpaste in the toiletries department, you’ll be sorely disappointed. (OK, I may be exaggerating slightly, but trust me when I say, only very slightly!)
If, like I was, you’ve had little to do with real China, you’re probably wondering why on earth this is the case?
Surely, you ponder, Chinese consumers would be open to new products, more choice, a wider variety of goods lining their shelves? Particularly if they’re made right here on home soil? Right?!
If you watch the news or read the paper, it’s been hard to miss the rapid rate in which China has progressed from an isolated economy into a global powerhouse.
With that, we’ve witnessed how quickly global brands (at least those who’ve managed to penetrate the market) like Starbucks, McDonalds, Apple and of course the plethora of designer labels have been accepted and adopted enthusiastically by locals.
In fact, China has for all intents and purposes become renowned as a country bearing the world’s most avid luxury shoppers. Now that’s quite a title!
Hence, you can imagine my
surprise, dismay, utter disappointment, when I arrived in downtown Xi’an only to discover there are quite a few gaps on the shelves when it comes to toiletries, cosmetics, toys, household items, food etc….etc.
Even a desperate browse online for Christmas shopping at Amazon China was met with a distinctly rationed supply of goods. (FYI, Amazon from any other country can’t deliver to China.)
(Of course, being the savvy shopper that I am, we did manage to snaffle a few items from Santa, including a giant paddling pool. (It came without a pump and deflated after day one, but that’s a story for another day!))
So, more than a little perplexed, I delved a little deeper, explored a little further and…’huzzah’… it all became a little clearer.
For a start, ask any business-savvy person ‘in the know’ and they’ll tell you trading in China is no straightforward task. A Forbes opinion piece last year on America’s trade policy quoted: “Any corporation that wants to sell in China must not only manufacture there but bring its best technology. Then it is expected to export it back to the United States.” As far as China importing American products, it’s often a no go zone. This pattern has been similar for most western countries.
They call it Chinese protectionism and it’s very clear, China is protective about what it ‘imports’ into the country.
So despite the fact that almost every thing you can buy is made here on Chinese soil, they are made for the ‘western’ market, not China…. and more often than not, never the twain shall meet.
From a business point of view, China’s complex legislative and political system is difficult to navigate, especially for a brand that does not have a local partner.
Many global brands have been trying for decades to capitalize on the world’s most populous nation (wouldn’t you be trying to engage 1.3 billion newly cashed up consumers), but for the majority, progress has been slow.
In second tier cities, it’s made even harder by a lack of demand for particular products and the fact that big companies need to cultivate relationships with local government.
Even if conglomerates can forge ties with China and are given the green light, multinational firms trying to woo Chinese consumers need to think outside the box or risk failing miserably.
Chinese may have a penchant for luxury goods, but what’s perceived as luxury is not necessarily the same as what the rest of the world covets.
In China, luxury is not necessarily about price point. A large part of China is still relatively poor and for them a night out at Pizza Hut rather than a fancy 5-Star hotel can be far more appealing.
A flimsy social safety net means for tens of millions of Chinese, the priority is saving for their own education, healthcare and retirement.
And while consumer spending has been rising along with China’s prosperity, it’s done so almost in spite of an economic model geared almost exclusively toward production rather than domestic consumption.
The place renowned for delivering low-cost goods to Western consumers doesn’t always do the same for its own people.
Apple laptops are made at a Chinese factory that grants a rebate on China’s 17 per cent value added tax, as long as those computers are exported and sold overseas.
Before that same machine can be sold domestically, it is first sent to Hong Kong, (an SAR of China) then returned to the mainland with a 20 per cent import tariff.
It also explains why Chinese pour over the border into Hong Kong in their droves….like bees to honey – quite simply, it’s cheaper!
As I write this though, it seems the tide might be turning. It’s been revealed from this month, China will cut import taxes on a range of overseas goods by an average of 50 per cent in an effort to boost global brands in China and also give a lift to domestic consumption in the world’s second biggest economy. (I may yet be singing “Let it Go” with the rest of the world.)
Price point aside, understanding the consumer is also key and a quote I read in The Economist recently, pretty well summed it up: “In China, trying to sell Cheese is like trying to sell stinky tofu in Switzerland.”
So, after overcoming my initial shock…. it now makes perfect sense that I struggle to get my favorite Cadbury block of chocolate at the supermarket.
Seeking approval from China is tough, persuading a nation of non-chocolate lovers even tougher!
30 years ago most Chinese had never tasted chocolate. For them it’s far from a common snack (yes, feel free to call chocolate a snack!) and even today is usually reserved by the Chinese for gift giving (probably to salivating foreigners like myself!)
In China, if you’re lucky enough to be accepted into the retail market, it’s about getting the formula right.
This is a country that cares a lot about history, heritage and culture. Those companies that connect to the Chinese heritage are much more likely to prosper. Take designer brand Louis Vuitton. All LV stores carry artwork relating to the local area; that’s a move that resonates well in the Chinese market.
It seems Colonal Sanders is not the only one that’s nailed this recipe for success. The seven secret spices may have been tweaked for the Chinese palate and it’s working.
In the US, KFC is dwarfed by McDonalds; in China KFC has 3300 restaurants and counting – more than three times McDonalds.
On the menu there are fewer buckets of chicken wings and tasty chips, with more congee and rice porridge tempting consumers with what they know and love.
Crest brand of toothpaste has also become hugely popular in China. With flavors like lemon, tea, salt and honey, I can’t imagine why! But as they say (and I’m sure Crest wholeheartedly agrees) “there’s no accounting for taste!”
Those big brands who’ve dumped their existing products on the Chinese with little thought have struggled for a slice of the market.
Chinese people are also known for purchasing something they can use (showcase) in public. That flash BMW you see cruising the streets or that Gucci handbag swung over his or her shoulder (Chinese men are also partial to a designer purse) are more sought after than things for the household.
Home Depot, an American DIY chain struggled to crack the China market for years after trying to persuade middle class Chinese to decorate their home.
Ironically, Ikea is coming to Xi’an this year….(cue fist pumps) whether it is successful remains to be seen, but so far in China they are claiming victory, with 20 plus stores. The key to their success? Localizing for the Chinese market. Check out this video! (I know where to go for a snooze.)
So, by now, you’re probably getting the idea, that what’s made in China is not necessarily found in China, and if it is… and it’s affordable, it’s usually because big brands got the formula right.
Of course this equation can create a slight dilemma for us expats homesick for a local fix. Plunged into a frenzy of dim sum, endless rows of toothpaste and Hello Kitty fever, what’s a Waigouren (foreigner) to do?
A) Suck it up
B) Stock up on trips back home….
Thankfully there is a third option, with foreign businesses starting to capitalize on the growing expat market. Jinkou is just one online company that gives you instant access to those familiar brands you know and love. Hello Cheetos and Kraft Macaroni Cheese!
Companies are also spotting opportunities to help out expats with private mail boxes. U.S Global Mail is one such company who recently came to me with their offer of a private mail box.
You can purchase things online in the US that you can’t purchase in person or online in China and have them sent to your own specific US address (not a PO Box) and then shipped right to your doorstep.
With a few kids’ birthdays coming up, I decided Hello Kitty had had her day and to test them out with an order for some much desired Peppa Pig items!
Within a few days my box of goodies was in my own virtual private mail box. The labels were scanned so I could see what it was and I could choose the method of shipping and whether or not I wanted the parcel opened and repackaged or sent with other items I’d ordered.
Not only can you use them to purchase those much craved for home staples, you can have your ordinary every day bills sent to your virtual private mailbox.
We all know those pesky bank statements and forms that quickly pile up and if you move around a lot, it’s easy to miss important documents, sent to old addresses. If everything is forwarded to Global Mail, they’ll simply scan the item and put them in the virtual mail box for you to look at. You can then decide if you want them to open it for a closer look, send it on to you or simply dump it in the trash. For some expats it’s a lifeline, allowing them to get vital medication shipped in from home. This blog post by DC Rainmaker in Paris, helps explain the lowdown. I’m incredibly happy to report, despite the often difficulties faced in getting mail in China, Peppa Pig’s classroom made it right to my door!
So next time you ask me if I’m shopping up a storm in China, you’ll know the rather grim answer (did I mention the hotelier’s quite happy about the money I’m saving?)! (Admittedly I’m still getting a retail fix every now and then at H & M and Zara, so all is not lost.)
Oh and if you announce you’re visiting China, you won’t be surprised when I request a block or two of Cadbury’s peppermint chocolate, will you!
This is China.
Latest posts by Nicole Webb (see all)
- And the Winner is….Bali! Trip Advisor’s Destination of the Year – Here’s Why! - May 22, 2018
- Back to China: The Place Where Anything is Possible - May 3, 2018
- Bula! Is Fiji Worth Putting on Your Travel List? - February 7, 2018